1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

[USE THIS] Signature critique template.

Discussion in 'Signatures and Small Art' started by Arzoroc, Sep 2, 2011.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Arzoroc

    Arzoroc Moderator Staff Member

    Oct 12, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    To make life easier for you and us, I'll get you this template. It will hopefully improve the way people answer to the people's arftworks. Just copy the following code everytime you want to post your CNC. Try to at least get 1 point for the pro/con section.
    [b][u]I like...[/u][/b]
    [b][u]I don't like...[/u][/b]
    [b][u]You could improve...[/u][/b]
    [b][u]All in all rating[/u][/b]
    Beginner [-----------[]------------] Awesome
    [b][u]Further tips/comments[/u][/b]
    Example usage:

    I like...
    - The colors
    - The text

    I don't like...
    - The lack of depth
    - The lighting
    - The smudging

    You could improve...
    Basically you should improve the lighting a lot + the smudging looks off. The problem with depth could be avoided by using the Rule of Thirds (focus on the render) or blurring the C4Ds in the background. The current C4D is just distracting from the render as a main focal point.

    All in all rating
    Beginner [------[]-----------------] Awesome

    Further tips/comments
    Go watch some tutorials about smudging on youtube, for example [LINK]. Also, you have got multiple lightsources, try to avoid that. The colors are good, try to use those on the text as well.


    I Know some of these points overlap, but this should at least stop the "I just dont like it" comments. Remember: Disliking an image is okay, as long as you give reasons and stay friendly. Also, as a wise man said, honest CNC always beats crap CNC.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page